This module is inactive in the selected year. The information shown below is for the academic year that the module was last running in, prior to the year selected.
2009/10 Undergraduate Module Catalogue
CLAS3980 Should We Ban Homer? Philosophers & Poetry in the Ancient World
20 creditsClass Size: 70
Module manager: Prof M F Heath
Email: M.F.Heath@leeds.ac.uk
Taught: Semesters 1 & 2 (Sep to Jun) View Timetable
Year running 2009/10
This module is approved as an Elective
Module summary
Poetry and drama enjoyed high prestige in ancient culture, and had a powerful impact on audiences and readers. Ancient philosophers responded to this cultural phenomenon in many different ways. Plato argued that poetry was profoundly damaging, psychologically, ethically and politically, and in need of radical reform. By contrast, Aristotle regarded poetry as a natural human practice that had developed over time into its optimal forms. Later thinkers in the Platonist tradition looked ways to make poetry harmless (and even beneficial) without radical political reform, and tried to reconcile Plato and the poets. This module will study and assess a range of these responses to poetry, and will also consider their relationship to modern debates on related issues - political (e.g. censorship), scientific (e.g. the evolutionary psychology of literature) and educational (e.g. the psychological implications of the internet).Objectives
On completion of this module, students should have acquired an understanding of a range of ancient philosophical responses to poetry and drama; have discussed and critically evaluates those responses, orally and in writing; and have considered the relevance of the ancient thinking on poetry to modern debates on related issues, political, scientific and educational.Learning outcomes
On completion of this module, students should be familiar with a range of ancient philosophical responses to poetry, including (as core instances): Plato's critique of poetry's psychological and political effects; Aristotle's conception of poetry as a natural human practice; Plutarch's discussion of poetry as an educational resource. They should have an understanding of these responses in their original cultural context, and should have considered their relationship to modern debates on related issues, political (e.g. censorship), scientific (e.g. the evolutionary psychology of literature) and educational (e.g. the psychological implications of the internet).
Skills outcomes
On successful completion of this module, students should be able to interpret and evaluate ancient philosophical views on poetry; to relate them to each other and to their respective cultural contexts; and to assess the relevance of the ancient debates to modern thinking on related topics.
Syllabus
Cultural background: why ancient philosophers thought that poetry and drama were important and potentially problematic. Why Plato thought that poetry was dangerous, and his political response to the threat. Why Aristotle's approach to poetry was fundamentally different from Plato's. How Plutarch proposed to turn the dangerous elements of poetry to educational advantage. How and why later Platonists attempted to reconcile Plato with poetry. Political, scientific and educational perspectives on literature and entertainment in modern discussion.
Teaching methods
Delivery type | Number | Length hours | Student hours |
Lecture | 15 | 1.00 | 15.00 |
Seminar | 4 | 1.00 | 4.00 |
Private study hours | 181.00 | ||
Total Contact hours | 19.00 | ||
Total hours (100hr per 10 credits) | 200.00 |
Private study
Reading primary texts: 50 hoursLecture preparation: 15x1 hours
Seminar preparation: 4x4 hours
Essay 1: 30 hours
Essay 2: 50 hours
Exam preparation: 20 hours
Opportunities for Formative Feedback
Seminar participation; semester 1 coursework.Methods of assessment
Coursework
Assessment type | Notes | % of formal assessment |
Essay | Maximum 1,000 words. | 20.00 |
Essay | Maximum 1,800 words. | 50.00 |
Total percentage (Assessment Coursework) | 70.00 |
Normally resits will be assessed by the same methodology as the first attempt, unless otherwise stated
Exams
Exam type | Exam duration | % of formal assessment |
Standard exam (closed essays, MCQs etc) | 2 hr | 30.00 |
Total percentage (Assessment Exams) | 30.00 |
Normally resits will be assessed by the same methodology as the first attempt, unless otherwise stated
Reading list
The reading list is available from the Library websiteLast updated: 12/05/2010
Browse Other Catalogues
- Undergraduate module catalogue
- Taught Postgraduate module catalogue
- Undergraduate programme catalogue
- Taught Postgraduate programme catalogue
Errors, omissions, failed links etc should be notified to the Catalogue Team.PROD